More than another affirmative action case: Laws that suppress racial minority voices
Jeffrey C. Sun
University of North Dakota
Overview
On March 25, 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court announced that in its new term beginning in October 2013, it would review another affirmative action case, Schuette v. Michigan Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action (BAMN).1 The plaintiffs in this case are a group of faculty members, prospective students, and then current students at the University of Michigan along with a group known as the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN). The organization leading the suit is often referred to as BAMN, which is an acronym constructed from the last four letters of the organization’s name. Could it be true? Two affirmative action cases within two years? Just last year, Neal Hutchens (2012) wrote in Developments about a then-upcoming case, Fisher v. University of Texas. In October 2012, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments for the Fisher case, which questions the use of race in college admissions for applicants who are not admitted based on their standing in the top 10% of their high school class. However, the Fisher case and those that preceded it faced a different line of legal analysis than what the upcoming BAMN case presents.
Previous Affirmative Action Cases
To recap from Hutchens’ (2012) article, several U.S. Supreme Court cases precede Fisher. In Regents of the University of California v. Bakke (1978), the Court provided three key legal lessons for higher education administrators. First, an admissions practice that uses a separate evaluation system (e.g., a separate evaluation committee and criteria) for minority applicants is impermissible. Second, a quota system based on race (i.e., a predetermined number of slots for racial minorities) is impermissible. Third, individualized applicant reviews, which are not based on a predetermined number of slots, may use race among one of many factors such as plus-point for racial minorities.
Then in 2003, the Court made clear from both Gratz v. Bollinger and Grutter v. Bollinger that race may be factored into admissions decisions with some limitations. According to Gratz (2003), we learned that awarding points for race is not acceptable when such a point system essentially places race as the decisive factor, not one of many factors of an overall applicant’s review. Grutter (2003) clarified the parameters further, stating: “Universities can, however, consider race or ethnicity more flexibly as a ‘plus’ factor in the context of individualized consideration of each and every applicant” (p. 334). In that case, the school’s use of race as a plus factor was part of an evaluation system that reviewed applications in a highly individualized, holistic process, so the use of race was clearly not a decisive factor. Stated another way, the Grutter case also informed higher education administrators that diversity may serve as a compelling interest. The opinion indicated that courts should defer to the University’s educational judgment as to whether diversity “is essential to its educational mission” (Grutter, 2003, p. 328). Thus, educational institutions have some levels of professional decision-making. Finally, Gratz emphasized that these policies emerge under protections from the 14th Amendment, which applies to public colleges,2 and from Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination based on race in educational programs or activities that receive federal financial assistance. Title VI applies to public and private colleges that receive federal financial assistance – which includes all public colleges and nearly all private colleges. Thus, these decisions are quite important to everyone in higher education.
The New Case
Before and after Gratz and Grutter, selected states started to pass bans prohibiting the use of race as a criterion for admission into public colleges. In November 2006, the state of Michigan joined three other states in passing a legal ban on race conscious admissions policies. In Michigan, the electorate voted through a state referendum, which is often referred to as Proposal 2, to ban race conscious admissions policies. Proposal 2 actually blocks the use of race and other factors in state operations, but the critical application here is the use of race for college admissions. In this case, the BAMN group got together and filed suit to contest the constitutionality of this state law. The defendants include the University of Michigan, Michigan State University, Wayne State University, and the State of Michigan.3
In 2008, a district court judge ruled on several motions about the case (BAMN, 2008). At that time, the judge ruled in favor of the State of Michigan finding no Equal Protection violation from Proposal 2. The plaintiffs appealed. In 2011, the Sixth Circuit for the U.S. Court of Appeals reversed the district court’s decision. That appellate panel ruled 2-1 that Proposal 2 provisions pertaining to higher education impermissibly alter the political process for racial minorities, thus making it illegal under the Equal Protection Clause (BAMN, 2011). Later, the whole Sixth Circuit panel decided to hear the case. In an 8-7 decision, the court upheld the ruling that Proposal 2 is unconstitutional. These decisions are held without any action until the Supreme Court decides the case.
In analyzing the BAMN case, the appellate courts referred to the political restructuring doctrine, which addresses the non-neutral allocation of power that places special burdens on racial minorities within the governmental process. To determine if the policy violates the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment, the court applied the political restructuring framework asking: (1) does the law have a racial focus targeting a policy of program that primarily benefits minorities, and (2) does the law reallocate political power or reorder the decision-making process in such a way that it places special burdens on minority groups to achieve their policy interests?
For the first prong, the court recognized that Proposal 2 has a racial focus in targeting the elimination of race conscious policies. For the second prong, the court examined two sub-parts: the political power and the special burdens on minorities. The court established that relevant admissions procedures are part of the political process. Noting the state of Michigan’s procedures for changing the admissions policies, the court observed that Michigan has elected governing boards, who set admissions policies. While responsibilities for day-to-day activities reside with campus administrators, the board exercises ultimate authority over admissions policies “making the policies themselves part of the political process” (BAMN, 2012, p. 482). As a noteworthy distinction, the court indicated that if the board did not have power and the control rested with the “politically unaccountable faculty members or admissions committees,” then the law would have had little impact on the political process and not met the second prong (BAMN, 2012, p. 480). Since the board had the authority and the law reordered the decision-making process, the court next conducted a comparative structural burden analysis. That is, it compared the political channels required to seek an admissions policy change. Table 1 displays the court’s tracing of the steps for a non-race admissions policy change and a race conscious admissions policy change.
Table 1: Comparing the Political Process
Non-Race Admissions Policy Change | Race Conscious Admission Policy Change |
[A] citizen interested in admissions policies benefitting legacy applicants—sons and daughters of alumni of the university—may lobby the admissions committees directly, through written or in-person communication. He may petition higher administrative authorities at the university, such as the dean of admissions, the president of the university, or the university’s board. He may seek to affect the election—through voting, campaigning, or other means—of any one of the eight board members whom the individual believes will champion his cause and revise admissions policies accordingly. And he may campaign for an amendment to the Michigan Constitution (BAMN, 2012, p. 484). | [T]he campaign for a constitutional amendment—is the sole recourse available to a Michigan citizen who supports enacting such policies. That citizen must now begin by convincing the Michigan electorate to amend its constitution—an extraordinarily expensive process and the most arduous of all the possible channels for change. Just to place a proposed constitutional amendment repealing Proposal 2 on the ballot would require either the support of two-thirds of both the Michigan House of Representatives and Senate…or the signatures of a number of voters equivalent to at least ten percent of the number of votes cast for all candidates for governor in the preceding general election. Once on the ballot, the proposed amendment must then earn the support of a majority of the voting electorate to undo Proposal 2’s categorical ban. After this successful constitutional amendment campaign, the citizen could finally approach the university—by petitioning the admissions committees or higher administrative authorities—to request the adoption of race-conscious admissions policies. By amending the Michigan Constitution to prohibit university admissions units from using even modest race-conscious admissions policies, Proposal 2 thus removed the authority to institute any such policy from Michigan’s universities and lodged it at the most remote level of Michigan’s government, the state constitution (BAMN, 2012, p. 484). |
Based on the analysis, which I placed in Table 1, the court concluded that racial minority students face the highest possible barrier to enact change compared to other non-race policies. In light of the review of the Michigan’s Proposal 2 to the two-prong test, the court ruled in favor of BAMN. The State Attorney General Bill Schuette filed an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court and on March 25, 2013 the Court granted a hearing.
Not Just Another Affirmative Action Case
Following the March 25, 2013 announcement of the Supreme Court’s upcoming review of BAMN, I heard and received emails from colleagues across the nation referencing this case as “another affirmative action case” on college admissions. I suppose that it may seem that way. Even Inside Higher Ed and the Washington Times headlined the news as “another affirmative action case” (Jaschik, 2013; Sherman, 2013). Similarly, on the front page of the Chronicle of Higher Education (2013), it highlighted the story as “Affirmative Action at Issue Once More” (p. A1). Sure, the case is about the contested Michigan referendum, which prohibits the use of race in college admissions, but as many thorough reporters such as Scott Jaschik (2013), Peter Schmidt (2013), and Mike Sherman (2013) made clear, this case is unlike past affirmative action cases before the U.S. Supreme Court. The issue in this case is not simply about whether diversity is a constitutionally permissible factor in admissions at public colleges. Instead, this case questions the constitutionality of the state referendum as a legal mechanism barring individuals based on race from taking action on their behalf. More specifically, this case is about whether the Michigan ban on affirmative action unfairly blocks access to racial minorities from being able to participate in the political process in such a burdensome manner that they cannot achieve their policy interests. Put simply, it’s not just about affirmative action in college admissions; it’s about the constitutional conceptions of fairness within the political process for racial minorities to enact change without special burdens.
Significance
This case is significant for several reasons.
1. Two federal appellate courts disagree.
The circumstances in the BAMN case resemble one from 1997. In that case, Coalition for Economic Equity v. Wilson, the plaintiffs contested the 1996 California referendum (also known as Proposition 209) that also banned race and gender-conscious policies in public operations such as college admissions at all of its public colleges or universities. Except, in the California referendum case, the Ninth Circuit for the U.S. Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the State of California and was not persuaded by the political restructuring argument. In BAMN the Sixth Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, who argued that banning race violated the minorities’ equal protection through the law.
2. Judicial value of diversity and minority rights might be illuminated.
We have a better sense about the legal value of diversity in college admissions. In the 2003 Grutter case, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that race is permissible as a factor for admission when applications are reviewed in a highly individualized, holistic manner. Depending on the statements made and the analytic approach, observers may have a better sense of where the Court stands on issues pertaining to minorities’ rights and the Court’s appreciable understanding of the high barriers for minorities with such laws. This insight is especially important in light of the changes in the Court’s composition4 since we last had an announced affirmative action decision.5
3. Eight state bans on affirmative action already exist.
There are eight states (AZ, CA, FL, MI, NE, NH, OK, and WA) with bans on affirmative action, and while those bans do not necessarily have the same set of facts to match this case, it’s quite possible that whatever happens in this case will alter the status of those bans. Further, there are states that are considering bans on affirmative action or may consider such bans depending on this case’s outcome.
4. State referenda challenges for other matters, besides race, may emerge.
This case is as much (and even more so) about state referenda as it is about affirmative action. A decision on this case may clarify the legal limits of state referenda. Scott Jaschik (2013) conveys quite well the connection between the Michigan Proposal 2 matter with other state referenda such as “California’s Proposition 8, which barred gay marriage in the state” (p. 1). As Jaschik and others rightly observe, these cases share legal issues about the denial of rights to selected individuals when a majority comes in to set the high standard for the insulated minorities to exercise their rights. Viewed another way, we may have a better understanding of political process and civil rights.
Immediate Action
With the conflict between the Ninth Circuit’s decision regarding California’s Proposition 209 and the Sixth Circuit’s decision regarding Michigan’s Proposal 2, the U.S. Supreme Court will need to determine how to analyze this case. It is quite likely that the Court may examine the same two prongs that the Sixth Circuit used.
In preparation for that application, student affairs professionals at public colleges and universities, particularly those with state referenda (i.e., AZ, CA, MI, NE, OK), should be evaluating and reporting the process in which students and other state citizens may enact changes to admissions policies. I strongly recommend that public colleges and universities, led by student affairs professionals, construct a committee to gather the data and lead such actions. The committee should analyze the process for a non-race-conscious policy and a race-conscious policy. Specifically, student affairs professionals should conduct a comparative structural burden analysis asking if a state ban does or would reorder the decision-making process and describe the expense, length, and complexity of each process. After collecting and analyzing data, the committee should write an internal report or a publicly disseminated white paper on the findings and recommendations.
Discussion Questions
- Does your state have, or has it discussed, a law that bans consideration of race or gender from state operations, including college admissions?
- Describe your current process in making admissions policies. When discussing the process, speak in terms of expense, length, and complexity of each process. What are the mechanisms or opportunities in which students, particularly racial minorities, may take to enact changes to the admissions policy?
- How might you educate students about the notion of barriers in the law for racial minorities and other insulated minority groups?
- What state level bans have been entertained or passed in your state (e.g., English only materials from state agencies, prohibiting gay marriage, barring undocumented students from enrollment or in-state tuition)?
Notes
- The full name of the Respondent in this case is Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN). The organization is often referred to as BAMN, which is an acronym constructed from the last four letters of the organization’s name.
- For purposes of this article, the term “colleges” refers to colleges and universities.
- The State of Michigan established the University of Michigan, Michigan State University, and Wayne State University with different authority and control, so each of those institutions have their own boards and maintain greater autonomy than the other colleges and universities in the State. The other colleges and universities in Michigan follow a different board model governed directly by the State.
- Justice Elena Kagan has recused herself from this case. Her recusal is likely because of her conflicts arising from previous role as U.S. Solicitor General.
- Of course, we will also find out soon the status of Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin.
References
Coalition for Economic Equity v. Wilson, 122 F.3d 692 (9th Cir. 1997).
Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action v. Regents of the Univ. of Mich., 539 F. Supp.2d 924 (E.D. Mich. 2008). [BAMN, 2008]
Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action v. Regents of the Univ. of Mich., 652 F.3d 607 (6th Cir. 2011). [BAMN, 2011]
Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action v. Regents of the Univ. of Mich., 701 F.3d 466 (6th Cir. 2012) (en banc). [BAMN, 2012]
Daniels, P. T. K., Gee, E. G., Sun, J. C., & Pauken, P. D. (2012). Law, policy, and higher education. New Providence, NJ: Matthew Bender & Company (LexisNexis).
Fisher v. Univ. of Tex. at Austin, 631 F.3d 213 (5th Cir. 2011) cert. granted, 132 S.Ct. 1536 (2012).
Gratz v. Bollinger, 539 U.S. 244 (2003).
Grutter v. Bollinger, 539 U.S. 306 (2003).
Hunter v. Erickson, 393 U.S. 385 (1969).
Hutchens, N. H. (2012). Supreme Court to revisit issue of race as a factor in higher education admissions. Developments, 10(2), Retrieved from http://www2.myacpa.org/developments/summer-2012/supreme-court-to-revisit…
Jaschik, S. (2013, Mar. 26). Another affirmative action case. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2013/03/26/supreme-court-takes-anothe…
Regents of the Univ. of Cal. v. Bakke, 438 U.S. 265 (1978).
Schmidt, P. (2013, Apr. 5). Supreme Court to look at Michigan’s ban on race-conscious admissions. Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A14.
Sherman, M. (2013, Mar. 25). Supreme Court to hear another affirmative-action case. Washington Times. Retrieved from http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/mar/25/supreme-court-hear-anoth…
Washington v. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1, 458 U.S. 457 (1982).
About the Author
Jeffrey C. Sun is an associate professor of educational leadership/higher education and affiliate associate professor of law at the University of North Dakota. He teaches and writes about legal issues pertaining to higher education.
Please e-mail inquiries to Jeffrey C. Sun.
Disclaimer
The ideas expressed in this article are not necessarily those of the Developments editorial board or those of ACPA members or the ACPA Governing Board, Leadership, or International Staff Office.
do you need a prescription for propecia In patients taking diuretics, volume depletion was slightly more common with dapagliflozin than with placebo in patients in the higher dose diuretic groups
estrace sale
[url=http://proscar.today/]discount propecia coupon[/url]
bupropion brand name
reputable indian online pharmacy
zyban 75 mg in uk
flomax cream
cialis price generic
buy aurogra 100
xenical pills uk
levothyroxine 50 mcg
medication zestoretic
clonidine 0.1 mg tab purepac
0.1 tretinoin cream buy online
over the counter flomax
zestril generic
can you buy elimite over the counter
can you buy baclofen over the counter us
levitra professional 20 mg
doxycycline 100mg cost uk
how to get accutane online
zithromax script
vermox price south africa
finasteride purchase
buy albuterol 4mg
trazodone 250 mg
vermox buy online uk
cheap canadian pharmacy
buy baclofen europe
order azithromycin without prescription
augmentin 1000 online
purchase retin a gel
silagra 100 uk
generic vardenafil canadian pharmacy
augmentin 500
diflucan pill
buy doxycycline capsules
cialis 10mg purchase
finasteride 5mg tabs
augmentin 375 mg tablets
vermox tablets price
cost toradol
50 mg atarax
price for 5 mg lisinopril
neurontin 400 mg cost
buy cheap doxycycline online
levitra 20mg australia
price of metformin in canada
azithromycin z-pak
how to get doxycycline
price of 100mcg synthroid
synthroid online prices
5 zoloft
generic bactrim online
levitra 10mg
bactrim 800 mg
best price for amoxicillin
how much is wellbutrin generic
buy azithromycin australia
cost of gabapentin 400 mg
where can i buy stromectol
synthroid
azithromycin 250 mg tablets
buy silagra india
[url=https://lisinopril.cfd/]lisinopril 5 mg buy online[/url]
effexor 300mg daily
furosemide 500mg tablets
generic paxil 20 mg
buying propecia online
trazodone 100mg price
glucophage price
inderal 40 uk
zoloft mexico
propecia pharmacy
buy fildena 50 mg
rx wellbutrin
zoloft 200 mg tablet
silagra 50 mg
xenical cost in south africa
buy zoloft on line no prescription
phenergan 25 mg prices
gabapentin in mexico
plaquenil retinal toxicity
robaxin 100mg tablets
where to purchase levitra
vermox canada otc
tadalafil cost in mexico
top online pharmacy india
paxil sleepiness
discount levitra
amoxicillin 125mg price
propecia 5mg buy
ordering neurontin online
cheap generic viagra india
accutane buy online
budesonide 90 mcg
fildena 100 canada
allopurinol 100 mg
toradol for kidney stone pain
100 mg furosemide
buy colchicine singapore
suhagra 50 mg tablet online purchase
bactrim online canada
how much is amoxicillin 500 mg
clonidine 300 mcg tablets
atarax prescription
generic levitra cheap
stromectol buy uk
ivermectin 3mg dosage
buy amoxicillin online mexico
doxycycline 200mg price in india
[url=http://synthroid.boutique/]synthroid tab 112 mcg[/url]
buy baclofen nz
325443009 prednisolone
wellbutrin prescription mexico
clonidine pills
suhagra 50 price in india
azithromycin 1
buy cialis through paypal
albuterol canada
paroxetine 40mg cost
allopurinol prescription online
how to buy viagra online uk
prednisolone 5 mg
effexor cost 75 mg
azithromycin gel brand name
synthroid 37 mcg
buy bupropion no prescription online canada
amoxicillin 500
diflucan 150 mg tablet in india
30 mg propranolol
buy zoloft usa
0.2 mg clonidine
budesonide brand
ventolin prescription cost
buy citalopram 20 mg online
generic name for ivermectin
diflucan buy online usa
can i buy propecia over the counter in canada
cheap viagra on line
buy propecia singapore
robaxin muscle relaxer
prednisolone 1
augmentin 875 prescription
plaquenil online
tretinoin 05 prices
can you buy toradol over the counter
uk zoloft
propecia generic price
buying zoloft online
canadian pharmacy bupropion
purchase bactrim online
lasix 40 mg daily
tretinoin cream 25
amoxicillin 2g
synthroid pill 88 mg
buy effexor xr generic
can i buy amoxicillin over the counter in mexico
synthroid 125 mcg price
purchase lasix
prozac 20 mg tablet price
prozac 60
vermox canada prescription
how much is lisinopril 10 mg
fluoxetine 10 mg tablet
lioresal 10mg
20 mg vardenafil
cost doxycycline australia
doxycycline 1mg
buy zestril online
zestril tablet
diflucan brand name 300mg
bupropion medication
where to buy xenical in usa
clonidine xr
amoxicillin medication
diflucan 200 mg tablet
stromectol tablets for humans for sale
baclofen uk pharmacy
amoxicillin 500 capsule
diflucan coupon
levitra buy online pharmacy
albuterol brand name usa
can you buy prednisone online
effexor 75mg coupon
amoxicillin cost
lyrica 100
effexor 225
prednisolone 25mg buy online
clonidine .3 mg
synthroid 37.5 mg
lioresal 10 mg tablets
plaquenil generic cost
can you buy azithromycin over the counter in usa
paxil prescription cost
how can i get metformin
lexapro cost
buy levitra online prescription
albuterol price in india
accutane price south africa
lisinopril 20 mg cost
[url=https://prednisolone.directory/]prednisolone cream uk[/url]
synthroid 125 mcg tablet
suhagra online purchase
price of azithromycin tablets
silagra 25 mg price
can i buy diflucan over the counter uk
order generic trazodone
toradol tabs
prednisolone price us
synthroid 1.25 mcg
12.5 mg paxil
propecia medicine
amoxicillin 250 mg capsule price
accutane 2017
fluoxetine 10 mg
gabapentin brand name in india
lisinopril cost
doxycycline 20 mg capsules
gabapentin prescription cost
can i buy metformin without prescription
diflucan tablets over the counter
metformin 500 mg coupon
suhagra 100 mg online
paroxetine 37.5 mg coupon
levitra us pharmacy
how to order doxycycline
where to buy generic propecia uk
where to buy cheap synthroid
prozac australia prescription
propranolol pill
silagra 100 for sale
ivermectin 200
accutane in uk
retinal prescription facecream
amoxicillin 500 mg discount
buy levitra canada
can you buy dapoxetine over the counter
buy accutane singapore
doxcyclene
canada pharmacy online
50 mg gabapentin
female cialis
finasteride over the counter
furosemide 40 mg over the counter
xenical orlistat
generic lexapro
buy prozac cheap
vermox online sale usa
finasteride 1mg discount coupon
amoxicillin 500mg buy
buy xenical cheap
doxycycline 40mg capsules
fluoxetine 40 mg prices
budesonide cream
0.5 albuterol
effexor xr 75
fildena canada
zoloft 50mg coupon
toradol cost
300 wellbutrin
vermox 500mg price
where to buy albuterol
diflucan men
drug amoxicillin 500mg
amoxicillin 67
toradol 20 mg
doxycycline 20 mg price
zoloft india
175 mg zoloft
medicine augmentin 375
over the counter amoxicillin australia
buy cheap prozac online
brand name levitra without prescription
effexor buy in canada
lisinopril pills 2.5 mg
suhagra 50 mg price in india
05 clonidine
budecort price
lisinopril over the counter
ventolin cream
buy lyrica online india
where to buy lexapro
diflucan from india
how to purchase clomid
doxycycline price australia
toradol pill 10mg
generic levitra from canada
baclofen medication
propecia 5mg australia
albuterol cost
best price for sildenafil medicine
toradol 15 mg
celexa 40 mg
suhagra for sale
economy pharmacy
diflucan buy
ventolin over the counter nz
buying diflucan over the counter
trazodone 50 mg pill
doxycyline online
affordable pharmacy
safe canadian pharmacies
buy budesonide
average cost of zyban
vermox canada
doxycycline tablets buy online
amoxicillin 500mg price canada
amoxicillin capsules for sale
how can i get doxycycline
vermox tablets where to buy
furosemide tablets australia
prozac 20 mg price in usa
med pharmacy
augmentin 875 125
propranolol hydrochloride
where to buy propranolol
silagra 100 price
baclofen online no prescription
diflucan online usa
buy accutane 10mg online
generic zoloft 25 mg
prednisolone tablets for sale
lowest cost generic cialis
cheapest generic propecia
neurontin 10 mg
generic neurontin 300 mg
buy generic diflucan
neurontin 800 pill
medication augmentin 875
augmentin 500 125 mg price
retin a cream online india
amoxicillin 250 mg price in india
10 mg metformin 12.5
trazodone 150 tab
doxycycline 100 mg tablet cost
buy accutane 10mg
buy paroxetine 30mg
buy generic cialis mastercard
synthroid 175 mcg
accutane cost australia
buy toradol online canada
clonidine for sleep in adults
toradol 10mg
zithromax over the counter canada
propeciaoffers.com
lisinopril best price
prednisone 10mg canada
plaquenil arthritis
online pharmacy pain medicine
get clomid online
108mg albuterol
lisinopril 20 mg for sale
amoxicillin 625mg tablet
colchicine brand
synthroid 05 mg
paxil tablets in india
trazodone discount
prozac 2019
baclofen prescription cost
gabapentin 150 mg capsules
doxycycline cheap
diflucan 150 mg fluconazole
doxycycline 100mg coupon
silagra 100mg uk
[url=https://propranolol.cfd/]propranol online[/url]
celexa 60 mg cheap no prescription
doxycycline gel in india
buy propecia in india
Fantastic blog. Awesome.
10mg fluoxetine
I very delighted to find this internet site on bing just what I was searching for as well saved to fav .pitit manman mari
how much is lisinopril 10 mg
cheap albuterol online
propecia prescription uk
lisinopril 40 mg price in india
diflucan prescription cost
neurontin price comparison
combivent price in india
dapoxetine 30mg price in india
[url=https://silagra.cyou/]silagra online india[/url]
buy silagra online uk
effexor-xr
order retin a gel
finasteride online 1mg
allopurinol 100 mg
finasteride 5 mg tablet cost
robaxin 500mg cost
amoxicillin 1g price
ventolin generic
ventolin inhalador
propranolol 150 mg
desyrel 25 mg
order neurontin over the counter
lisinopril generic 20 mg
gabapentin 2400 mg
canadian pharmacy world coupon
buy diflucan no prescription
thecanadianpharmacy
lioresal 10mg
retin a 0.025
diflucan uk online
paroxetine generic india
prednisone pill 20 mg
can you buy stromectol over the counter
accutane 2017
Very good blog post.Really thank you! Want more.
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic post. Cool.
albuterol pills
albuterol medication pills
baclofen 0.01
synthroid 100 mcg coupon
buy generic dapoxetine online
neurontin cost
40 mg daily prednisone
accutane prescription price
buy semaglutide oversees
I am so grateful for your article post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
Thanks again for the post.Much thanks again. Really Great.
ozempic semaglutide tablets 3mg
semaglutide retail price
semaglutide 14mg tablets
Enjoyed every bit of your blog article.Thanks Again. Will read on…
semaglutide 14
buy ozempic for weight loss
rybelsus 14mg tablets
ozempic tablets 7 mg
I am so grateful for your blog. Really Cool.
Thank you ever so for you blog. Great.
semaglutide generic cost
wegovy tablets buy
buy semaglutide in canada
wegovy medication
buy semaglutide cheap
buy rybelsus in mexico
semaglutide 14mg
buy ozempic from india
rybelsus oral medication
ozempic tab 14mg
buy ozempic in mexico
rybelsus 21 mg
wegovy 3 mg
generic semaglutide cost
generic semaglutide for weight loss
generic semaglutide cost
rybelsus buy australia
order rybelsus online
buy wegovy online from india
semaglutide tablets 7 mg
rybelsus price
buy ozempic online from india
wegovy oral medication
purchase wegovy
semaglutide tablets buy
rybelsus best price
buy wegovy in mexico
buy wegovy
purchase ozempic
rybelsus canada
buy wegovy online from india
rybelsus prescription
rybelsus without prescription
where to buy semaglutide
generic wegovy cost
ozempic tablets 7 mg
rybelsus canada pharmacy prices
buy wegovy
brand semaglutide
wegovy weight loss
buy wegovy in mexico
buy rybelsus online no script
order semaglutide online
This is one awesome blog post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
I really like and appreciate your blog.Much thanks again. Really Great.
buy ozempic from canada online
purchase semaglutide
Very good blog. Great.
I think this is a real great article.Thanks Again. Great.
ozempic tablets for weight loss cost
buy ozempic for weight loss
rybelsus tab 3mg
semaglutide lose weight
semaglutide 14mg
Thanks for the article.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.
rybelsus for sale
I cannot thank you enough for the blog article.Really thank you! Great.
ozempic tab 7mg
purchase wegovy
semaglutide lose weight
generic ozempic cost
buy semaglutide in canada
buy semaglutide
semaglutide 21 mg
rybelsus generic cost
semaglutide canada pharmacy prices
Thanks a lot for the blog post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
Thanks a lot for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
semaglutide for diabetes
Really informative blog.Much thanks again. Awesome.
I truly appreciate this article. Really Cool.
wegovy from canada
rybelsus for sale
ozempic tab 14mg
wegovy generic cost
wegovy tab 14mg
buy semaglutide
buy ozempic canada
wegovy tablets for weight loss cost
semaglutide 7mg
Looking forward to reading more. Great blog post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
Thank you for your article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
semaglutide where to buy
wegovy pill form
rybelsus buy australia
buy rybelsus
Very nice blog post. definitely love this site.<a href="https://www.cse.google.ki/url?sa=t
semaglutide canada pharmacy
semaglutide tablets cost
Thanks a lot for the post. Awesome.
Im obliged for the blog article.Thanks Again. Awesome.
buy semaglutide pill form for adults
generic rybelsus cost
rybelsus drug
wegovy pill
semaglutide 14mg tablets
rybelsus canada pharmacy prices
wegovy pill form
wegovy for sale
semaglutide buy online
Really enjoyed this blog post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.
Thanks for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
buy wegovy online from india
buy semaglutide online canada
semaglutide tablets for weight loss cost
semaglutide pills
purchase wegovy
ozempic for weight loss without diabetes
wegovy oral medication
I truly appreciate this article post.Much thanks again. Great.
I appreciate you sharing this blog post.Thanks Again. Want more.
semaglutide weight loss
semaglutide from canada
wegovy canada
buy ozempic uk
rybelsus tablets 7 mg
generic semaglutide
semaglutide for weight loss
buy wegovy online no script
Thanks for the post.Thanks Again.
Thanks so much for the blog. Awesome.
rybelsus drug
semaglutide sale
buy rybelsus in canada
Im obliged for the blog.Thanks Again. Want more.
wegovy australia online
semaglutide rx
buy wegovy in mexico
rybelsus semaglutide tablets 3mg
where to buy semaglutide
I cannot thank you enough for the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
Enjoyed every bit of your blog article.Much thanks again. Cool.
wegovy online order
wegovy weight loss
rybelsus online prescription
rybelsus tablets buy
buy ozempic pill form for adults
semaglutide
wegovy 3mg
wegovy online cheap
semaglutide tab 14mg
rybelsus 3 mg
wegovy online order
buy ozempic online from india
wegovy from canada
wegovy tablets for weight loss
wegovy lose weight
Very well presented.very quote was awesome and thanks for sharing the content.-vox live kostenlos
wegovy generic cost
ozempic injections
rybelsus tablets for weight loss cost
semaglutide tablet
wegovy canada pharmacy
semaglutide tablets
semaglutide australia
semaglutide price
buy ozempic from canada
semaglutide canada pharmacy
order wegovy online
rybelsus online cheap
semaglutide pill form
rybelsus buy uk
semaglutide xr
semaglutide 3 mg tablet
order semaglutide online
buy semaglutide in canada
ozempic tab 3mg
wegovy buy online
ozempic semaglutide tablets 7.5 mcg
semaglutide 3mg
wegovy diabetes medication
buy wegovy online no script needed
ozempic for weight loss
wegovy tab 3mg
rybelsus generic cost
semaglutide 3mg
buy wegovy in mexico
semaglutide for weight loss without diabetes
wegovy 3 mg
rybelsus 7 mg
order rybelsus online
wegovy for sale
[url=http://rybelsus.party/]wegovy over the counter[/url]
wegovy buy australia
wegovy prescription
semaglutide 3mg
ozempic tablets
semaglutide australia
wegovy without prescription
rybelsus prescription
rybelsus 14
semaglutide diabetes medication
semaglutide injection
buy semaglutide from india
buy rybelsus online from india
order rybelsus
rybelsus canada pharmacy prices
cheap semaglutide
rybelsus 3 mg tablet
wegovy without prescription
wegovy buy uk
rybelsus australia online
ozempic online
wegovy xl
rybelsus 7 mg
wegovy without prescription
semaglutide online pharmacy
wegovy 7 mg
ozempic tablets for weight loss cost
rybelsus canada pharmacy
wegovy medication
rybelsus australia online
order semaglutide online
semaglutide tab 3mg
order rybelsus
wegovy canada pharmacy prices
wegovy online uk
rybelsus buy from canada
semaglutide tab 14mg
wegovy online uk
semaglutide 21 mg
ozempic tablets buy
rybelsus semaglutide
[url=https://rybelsus.quest/]semaglutide diabetes medication[/url]
wegovy 7mg
buy ozempic in mexico
semaglutide weight loss
wegovy tab 7mg
wegovy order
generic rybelsus
rybelsus drug
rybelsus where to buy
wegovy medication
semaglutide 14mg tablets
buy rybelsus canada
generic wegovy for weight loss
buy rybelsus in mexico
rybelsus tablets cost
generic ozempic cost
Major thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
Major thanks for the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
buy wegovy canada
order semaglutide
semaglutide uk
ozempic tablets buy
ozempic tablets buy
generic semaglutide for weight loss
wegovy tab 7mg
rybelsus 3 mg
buy ozempic online pharmacy
semaglutide from canada
generic semaglutide
purchase ozempic
wegovy tablets for weight loss cost
buy semaglutide online no script needed
buy ozempic from canada online
wegovy semaglutide
Thank you for great article. look forward to the continuation.NEW Bose QuietComfort Wireless Noise Cancelling Headphones Bluetooth Over Ear Headphones with Up To 24 Hours of Battery Life Black – Hot Deals
rybelsus semaglutide tablets
rybelsus tab 14mg
buy semaglutide online pharmacy
wegovy tablets for weight loss
rybelsus tablets buy
[url=http://semaglutideozempic.shop/]rybelsus tablets for weight loss[/url]
wegovy order
semaglutide from canada
rybelsus xl
buy rybelsus
I think this is a real great article. Will read on…
semaglutide rybelsus
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog.Really thank you! Really Great.
rybelsus 14mg
rybelsus online order
rybelsus tab 14mg
rybelsus over the counter
semaglutide for diabetes
wegovy buy online
buy semaglutide in mexico
Major thanks for the blog article.Really thank you! Great.
Looking forward to reading more. Great blog article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
brand ozempic
rybelsus online prescription
semaglutide medication
rybelsus pill form
buy rybelsus online no script needed
rybelsus for sale
buy rybelsus
wegovy uk
This is one awesome blog post.Really thank you! Cool.
I think this is a real great blog post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.
semaglutide pill
generic ozempic cost
buy ozempic from canada online
buy ozempic in mexico
buy rybelsus online no script
buy wegovy from canada
wegovy where to buy
semaglutide online order
wegovy 14
semaglutide without prescription
buy ozempic
ozempic injections
wegovy medicine
wegovy tab 7mg
buy ozempic online canada
where can i buy ozempic
buy wegovy canada
cheap semaglutide
wegovy canada
ozempic tablets for weight loss
rybelsus tablets 7 mg
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog article.Thanks Again. Great.
Muchos Gracias for your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.
wegovy
wegovy oral medication
semaglutide price
rybelsus 3 mg tablet
I cannot thank you enough for the article.Thanks Again. Want more.
rybelsus uk
wegovy online pharmacy
wegovy 14
rybelsus 3 mg
wegovy sale
rybelsus australia
Thanks so much for the blog post.Thanks Again. Great.
rybelsus 7 mg
rybelsus diabetes
semaglutide for weight loss without diabetes
semaglutide online pharmacy
rybelsus tab 3mg
wegovy 7 mg
buy ozempic for weight loss
semaglutide without prescription
wegovy without prescription
rybelsus semaglutide tablets
semaglutide uk
Thanks-a-mundo for the article.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
Very neat blog post.Much thanks again. Awesome.
wegovy canada pharmacy prices
ozempic injections
Im thankful for the article post.Really thank you! Great.
Muchos Gracias for your blog. Much obliged.
buy ozempic in canada
semaglutide coupon
Very neat blog article. Fantastic.
Im obliged for the post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
buy ozempic online cheap
where to buy semaglutide
rybelsus pill
rybelsus pill form
semaglutide sale
semaglutide pill
semaglutide tab 3mg
Thanks a lot for the article post.Thanks Again. Will read on…
buy ozempic pill form for adults
Say, you got a nice post.Really thank you!
buy semaglutide
wegovy diabetes medication
Major thanks for the article.Thanks Again. Really Great.
Thanks a lot for the article post. Will read on…
wegovy best price
where to buy ozempic
wegovy xl
ozempic coupon
buy semaglutide canada
rybelsus price
wegovy sale
order semaglutide online
best brand metformin
canadianpharmacyworld com
synthroid 15 mg
Thanks again for the blog post. Really Cool.
synthroid 0.075 mg
Say, you got a nice article.Much thanks again. Awesome.
450 mg synthroid
tadalafil paypal
synthroid 75 mcg tablet price
azithromycin medication
zestoretic 20-25 mg
wow, awesome blog article.Thanks Again. Fantastic.
zestoretic 10 12.5
Say, you got a nice blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
cheap tadalafil
buying prednisone
synthroid 88 mcg price
canadianpharmacymeds
levoxyl synthroid
buy cialis 20mg online uk
15 mg prednisone daily
canadian pharmacy online store
5mg cialis
antibiotics zithromax
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
azithromycin 500 mg tablet cost
synthroid brand name cost
canada rx pharmacy world
Great blog post.Really thank you! Keep writing.
lisinopril 20 mg prices
synthroid cost usa
tadalafil 20 mg mexico
happy family pharmacy
prednisone 100 mg daily
online canadian pharmacy coupon
valtrex 400 mg
valtrex in australia
zestoretic coupon
metformin hcl 1000
Great post Thank you. look forward to the continuation. – boys hey dude shoes
synthroid 100 mg daily
synthroid 110 mcg
canadian pharmacy store
prednisone 60
synthroid 200 mcg
canadian happy family store pharmacy
synthroid 0.05 mcg
canadapharmacy24h
where to get prednisone
valtrex generic purchase
good pharmacy
canada pharmacy not requiring prescription
synthroid 125 mcg coupon
tadalafil 40
how to get valtrex without a prescription
prednisone in mexico
generic cialis online australia
glucophage brand
cialis daily 5mg online
happy family store canada
cost of cialis per pill
glucophage medicine
cost of prednisone 5mg tablets
Looking forward to reading more. Great blog post. Fantastic.
I value the post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
best generic cialis brand
prinivil 5 mg
prednisone 5mg
synthroid 0.137 mg
online pharmacy group
buy synthroid without prescription
lisinopril 40 mg prices
Very informative article.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.
This is one awesome blog. Awesome.
tadalafil from canada
lisinopril brand
where can i buy over the counter tadalafil 20mg
lisinopril 40 mg for sale
Hey, thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Will read on…
zithromax in usa
Appreciate you sharing, great article.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
prednisone 5052
synthroid 125 mcg coupon
Thanks for the blog.Thanks Again. Will read on…
synthroid tablets uk
Appreciate you sharing, great post.Really thank you! Really Great.
synthroid 125 mcg tablet cost
synthroid price india
order synthroid from canada
wow, awesome article post.Really thank you! Great.
legitimate online pharmacy
Thanks a lot for the article post. Awesome.
synthroid 25 mcg tabs
60 mg prednisone
synthroid 0.5 mcg
synthroid 75 mcg cheap no prescription
online pharmacy 365
I cannot thank you enough for the blog article. Fantastic.
Im obliged for the blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
indianpharmacy com
zestoretic online
canada drug pharmacy cialis
synthroid costs us
Thank you for your article. Will read on…
Im obliged for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
online pharmacy no presc uk
prednisone where can i buy
discount cialis tablets
glucophage 1000 mg price in india
rx pharmacy coupons
lisinopril 2.5 mg cost
[url=http://tadalafilstd.online/]cialis coupon 20mg[/url]
synthroid 50 mcg
american pharmacy
canadian pharmacy world
Fantastic blog.Thanks Again. Much obliged.
Thank you for your blog. Much obliged.
medical mall pharmacy
[url=http://bestmedsx.com/]online pet pharmacy[/url]
synthroid 150 mg
cheap valtrex for sale
metformin 1000 mg
cialis 40mg australia
buy synthroid 200 mcg
safe reliable canadian pharmacy
Thanks a lot for the article post. Keep writing.
Thanks-a-mundo for the blog article.Thanks Again. Really Cool.
lisinopril 25
prinivil coupon
Say, you got a nice blog post.Really thank you! Really Great.
Thanks again for the blog post. Keep writing.
lisinopril 2.5
can i buy lisinopril over the counter
zestril 5 mg
can you buy zithromax over the counter in australia
Awesome blog.Much thanks again. Will read on…
I value the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
best european online pharmacy
online pharmacy australia
brand name prednisone
united states tadalafil
Thanks again for the blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
Major thanks for the blog post.Really thank you! Awesome.
lisinopril 20 mg brand name
best metformin brand in india
Very good blog.Really thank you! Fantastic.
Really informative article post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
lisinopril 30 mg daily
lisinopril 20 mg no prescription
synthroid 25 mg
synthroid 0.25 mg
Enjoyed every bit of your blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.
wow, awesome blog post. Much obliged.
175 mg synthroid
price for 125mcg synthroid
generic cialis lowest price
synthroid cost usa
Thank you for your article.Much thanks again. Awesome.
synthroid tablets 100 mcg
rx cialis
best online pet pharmacy
A big thank you for your blog post.Really thank you! Awesome.
Hey, thanks for the blog article.Much thanks again. Awesome.
tadalafil 100 mg uk
best online pet pharmacy
where can i buy over the counter tadalafil 20mg
A round of applause for your article.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
azithromycin zithromax
synthroid 0.15 mg
prednisone 30 mg
Great blog post.Thanks Again. Great.
prednisone 10 mg tablet cost
lisinopril 200 mg
buy synthroid mexico
Thanks again for the blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
prinivil 5 mg
low cost online pharmacy
glucophage 850 price
tadalafil 10mg online india
Awesome blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
canadian pharmacy coupon code
I think this is a real great article.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
cheapest pharmacy for prescriptions
where to buy synthroid
I am so grateful for your post.Really thank you! Keep writing.
cost of synthroid brand name
buying prednisone on line
cost of brand name synthroid
how to buy metformin in canada